Name: Toppe Consulting
Price range: $

Toppe Consulting | Building Better Law Practices, One Attorney at a Time

The conversation inside a lot of law firms right now sounds the same. Rankings look fine. The website has not changed. The phone is quieter. Most partners put it down to a slow month.

The likelier explanation is that the link between ranking and clicking has come apart. A firm can hold position one, collect the impression, and never get the visit, because the answer arrived above the results.

What the Data Shows

How much do AI Overviews cut click-through rates?

Pew Research Center tracked the browsing of 900 U.S. adults in March 2025. When an AI summary appeared, users clicked a traditional search result in 8% of visits. With no summary, they clicked 15% of the time. Users clicked a link inside the summary itself in about 1% of visits.

That is close to half the click rate on affected queries. Pew’s July 2025 analysis also found that people ended the browsing session entirely on 26% of pages carrying an AI summary, against 16% of pages with standard results only. Roughly one in five searches in the study produced a summary.

A searcher who reads the answer and stops does not show up in a law firm’s inquiry log. Nothing in the firm’s analytics records the client it never met.

Why are firms noticing this now rather than in 2024?

AI Overviews launched in May 2024 and their coverage widened through 2025. Informational legal queries were among the categories most affected, so the decline built gradually rather than arriving in one month. Ranking dashboards stayed flat the whole time, which hid the click-rate drop underneath.

Why Legal Content Takes the Hit

Legal questions are mostly informational. Someone wants to know what to do after a car accident, or whether what happened at work counts as wrongful termination. They are trying to understand the situation before deciding whether to call anyone.

That is exactly the kind of question an AI summary handles well. Procedural explanation is what most law firm blog posts and practice area pages provide, so the content that drove the most traffic is the content most likely to be answered above the fold.

Gartner projected in February 2024 that traditional search engine volume would fall 25% by 2026 as chatbots and virtual agents absorb queries. Categories built on synthesized answers were named as the most exposed. Legal sits squarely in that group.

What does flat rankings plus falling traffic actually mean?

It usually means the rankings are intact and the clicks are going to the summary. Ranking still decides whether a page is eligible to be cited inside an AI Overview. It no longer decides whether anyone clicks. Impressions holding steady while clicks fall is the signature of that pattern.

What to Measure Now

Rankings, sessions, and conversions miss this entirely. A firm can rank, earn the impression, and receive no visit, and all three numbers will look unremarkable.

Four measures show the real picture. Click-through rate by query, tracked over 12 months rather than month to month. Whether the firm appears inside AI Overviews on its own key terms, checked by hand. Branded search and direct traffic volume, which show whether the firm is being remembered. Consultation requests, which show whether any of this is reaching intake.

How can a firm check its own exposure this week?

Open Search Console, filter Performance by query, and sort by impressions. Find the high-impression queries producing few clicks. Search those queries in an incognito window and note which ones trigger an AI Overview and whether the firm is cited inside it. Compare click-through rates on affected and unaffected queries.

That comparison separates an AI Overview problem from a rankings problem. The two call for different responses, and firms often assume the wrong one.

What This Is Not

Organic search is not finished for law firms. Queries that produce no AI Overview still generate clicks at historical rates. The shift has hit one category of query, and it happens to be the category that fed most informational traffic.

High-intent searches hold up better. Someone typing “hire a personal injury lawyer in Greenville” wants a firm to call, not a summary of tort law. That argues for weighting law firm SEO work toward transactional and local terms, while informational content keeps earning its place through citation and credibility rather than raw sessions.

The structural question is settled enough to plan around. Coverage has expanded steadily since launch and shows no sign of pulling back. Firms adapting well are doing three things at once: holding the technical and E-E-A-T foundation, structuring pages so answers can be extracted and cited, and strengthening local signals. The page-level requirements are covered in How Practice Area Pages Determine Which Law Firms Survive AI-Driven Search.

Toppe Consulting: Digital Marketing for Small Law Firms

Toppe Consulting works exclusively with solo practitioners and small law firms. Content is written in-house by Joe Toppe, a Managing Editor at PropertyCasualty360 and former Fox Business Network writer. No long-term contracts, and a clear quote upfront.

Our Services Include:

AEO for Law Firms — Pages structured so answer engines can read, extract, and cite them
GEO for Law Firms — Visibility work aimed at generative search rather than the blue links alone

Watching traffic fall while rankings hold?
Contact Toppe Consulting for a quote with no contract attached.

Works Cited

Chapekis, Athena. “Google Users Are Less Likely to Click on Links When an AI Summary Appears in the Results.” Pew Research Center, 22 July 2025, www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/07/22/google-users-are-less-likely-to-click-on-links-when-an-ai-summary-appears-in-the-results/. Accessed 22 Sept. 2026.

“Gartner Predicts Search Engine Volume Will Drop 25% by 2026, Due to AI Chatbots and Other Virtual Agents.” Gartner, Inc., 19 Feb. 2024, www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2024-02-19-gartner-predicts-search-engine-volume-will-drop-25-percent-by-2026-due-to-ai-chatbots-and-other-virtual-agents. Accessed 22 Sept. 2026.

Toppe Consulting provides digital marketing services to law firms. This website does not offer legal advice.